Paradise Dam Improvement Project – History

Paradise Dam Improvement Project

Paradise Dam, Queensland

Sunwater is planning for a new Paradise Dam wall on the Burnett River after newly identified issues show that no amount of improvement work will fix the existing dam.

Project background

Paradise Dam is located 80 kilometres southwest of Bundaberg, Queensland, Australia on the Burnett River. 

The dam is owned and operated by Queensland government-owned corporation, Sunwater and is part of the Bundaberg Water Supply Scheme which supplies water for irrigation and urban use in the Bundaberg Region and was not designed for flood mitigation. 

Paradise Dam is a 52-metre-high compacted concrete (RCC) gravity dam designed and constructed by the Burnett Dam Alliance from 2003-2005. It was completed in November 2005 at a cost of $266 million (AUD) with a storage capacity of 300,000 megalitres (ML). In December 2006, Sunwater acquired operations and ownership of Burnett Water Pty Ltd and its assets, including Paradise Dam. 

Following the unexpectedly severe damage to the dam and erosion of the riverbed immediately downstream of the dam apron after the January 2013 flood, a series of investigations began. These investigations, along with the development of subsequent technical reports between 2013 and 2019, revealed issues with the dam’s structural condition. This process culminated in 2019 with the discovery of concerns about the stability of the dam wall under extreme weather conditions. 

In April 2020, an independent Commission of Inquiry report confirmed structural and stability issues with the dam and outlined the design failure and poor concrete mix in the initial construction.  

During 2020 and early 2021 Sunwater lowered the dam (to EL 61.8m AHD) and completed essential works to improve the safety of the dam for people living downstream. These works reduced the risk of dam failure to a 1 in 5000-year event. Prior to the works, the dam failure risk was a 1 in 200-year event, such as the community experienced in 2013. The dam remains safe at the current lower supply level and will be so for the life of the project. However, it is still not within the acceptable level of risk for the long-term. 

As part of the essential works project, extensive testing identified further concerns about long-term strength and quality of the dam’s concrete, compounded by the low cement content in the concrete mix design in the existing dam. These issues are: 

  • Swelling clay: due to the porous nature of the concrete, low cement content, and high clay content including swelling clays, moisture causes repeated swelling and contracting over time. 
  • Cement leaching: due to the porous nature of the concrete, key ingredients that bond the cement leach out leading to deterioration and strength loss. 
  • Carbonation: the mix of carbon dioxide, moisture and cement results in low pH (increased acidity) and increases the effects of the swelling clay, resulting in lower overall concrete strength.  

A previously planned improvement project was expected to restore Paradise Dam to its full 300 gigalitre capacity by re-raising, strengthening and stabilising the existing dam wall, however a wide range of international and Australian experts verified these issues as unprecedented and unique to Paradise Dam, advising that repairing the existing dam wall is not feasible. 

Sunwater is now progressing a detailed business case for a new Paradise Dam wall, with project costs and timeframes to be confirmed as part of this process. Sunwater has appointed CPB Contractors and Georgiou as construction partner and GHD as the ongoing design partner for the project, which will ensure design and construction challenges are considered and addressed early.

Separate to planning for a new dam wall, Sunwater will also commence a detailed business case to expand the irrigation network within the Bundaberg Water Supply Scheme. This will build upon previous investigations to understand distribution constraints. Therefore, Sunwater will combine the two focuses into one detailed business case.

While determining details for the new wall at Paradise Dam and irrigation network capacity upgrades takes time, Sunwater is working as quickly as possible and will provide regular progress updates to the community.

Timeline

DateEvent  
January 2024 New dam wall and alliance announced  
April 2023 Submissions received from two shortlisted construction partner proponents.  
March 2023 Paradise Dam Road upgrades and road civil construction Works Expression of Interest released. GHD designer proposal received.  
February 2023 RFP for the construction alliance partner issued 
December 2023 Two construction alliance partners shortlisted  
October 2022 Additional geotechnical work completed for the year  EOI for the construction alliance partner closed 
11 February 2022 Australian Government announces project contribution of $600M  
8 February 2022 Queensland Government announces project funding commitment of $600M 
24 December 2021 Queensland Government announces Paradise Dam will be returned to its original height, as part of significant safety improvement works 
2 December 2021 Recommendation on the best long-term option and crest level to meet dam safety and long-term water demand objectives presented to the Cabinet Budget Review Committee (CBRC). 
October 2021 Completion of a Stage 1 detailed business case, with options analysis and a recommendation made to government. 
Continuing throughout 2021 Ongoing ancillary activities to be completed, including concrete infill in the riverbed downstream of the spillway apron (as preparatory works for future apron extension), further drilling for core samples and geological investigations and upgrade of downstream fish passage infrastructure.   
May 2021 Additional Sunwater‐led investigations plus concept designs and cost estimates for options refinement completed. DNRME‐led investigations for demand, for detailed options re-assessment completed. Sunwater-led investigations for alternate water supply options and yield assessments – completed. 
March 2021 BQ transitioned to DRDMW  
11 March 2021 Essential Work risk reduction communicated along with message that a Qld Government decision on the preferred long-term remediation solution by the end of 2021.  
May 2020 – January 2021 Essential Works to lower the dam wall to reduce risk of a dam failure. Spillway lowering completed in September 2020. Temporary crest completed in January 2021.  
September – October 2020 Demand survey open  
April 2020 Paradise Dam Commission of Inquiry provides Final Report  
February – June 2020 Further water releases for EW, associated with inflows, to maintain temporary full supply level 
February 2020 Building Queensland provided its options assessment report to the Queensland Government. This report recommended detailed review of three options and identified work and testing needed to be done before final designs and a business case can be completed 
December 2019 IGEM report handed down 
September – December 2019 Water releases commenced, and to manage dam at reduced temporary full supply level, considering dam safety risks and in preparation for EW 
September 2019 Queensland Government requested Building Queensland undertake an options assessment  
Aug 2019 – Sep 2019 Technical Review Panel workshop & Revised Assessment and Reports. Essential Works project initiated (Sep 2019). 
Feb 2019 – Sep 2019 Geotechnical Site Investigations & Laboratory Testing 
Dec 2018 – Feb 2019 Draft Revised Dam Stability Assessment 
2018 – present Preliminary design & Detailed Business Case planning for long-term improvement works (initially 2 shortlisted options) 
Apr 2017 – Jun 2018 Next stage improvements – Preliminary Business Case completed for remaining works 
May 2015 – Aug 2017 Initial improvements – monolith toe strengthening undertaken on Primary Spillway 
2015 – 2016 More detailed studies, Dam Safety Review and Comprehensive Risk Assessment 
2013 – Jan 2015 Initial investigations, Dam Safety Review and Comprehensive Risk Assessment 
March 2013 – December 2013 Emergency and interim flood repairs 
January 2013  Flood of record (outflows continued to 20 Mar 2013) 
December 2010  Passed first flood  
March 2010 First filled  
2005 Sunwater, which was not a member of the Alliance, directed to acquire the shares in Burnett Water and became the Dam’s operator. 
2003 -2005 Paradise Dam designed and constructed by the Alliance. Sunwater, which had expertise in dam design, provided technical advice to Burnett Water about preliminary design. 

Earlier works

2013-2014 works

A Dam Safety Review and Comprehensive Risk Assessment at Paradise Dam was conducted following a record flood event in January 2013. Engineering assessments identified areas of the dam that could be future strengthened to withstand extreme weather events.

Stage 1 of works included:

  • strengthening and additional concrete protection to the base of the primary spillway
  • downstream protection of the left-hand side dam wall
  • construction of an access and drainage culvert.

Works milestones

  • Flood repair works carried out in 2013 and 2014
  • Further improvement works completed in mid-2017.

Essential Works

The Essential Works, which reduced pressure on the dam wall in the case of a significant flood event, were a short-term risk reduction measure while a longer-term dam remediation plan was confirmed.

These works reduced the risk of dam failure to a 1 in 5000-year event. Prior to the works, the dam failure risk was a 1 in 200-year event, such as the community experienced in 2013.

Preparation activities for the Essential Works commenced in April 2020 and lowering of the spillway commenced in May 2020 and was completed in September 2020, with final pours for the spillway’s concrete crest completed at the end of January 2021.

The final ancillary activities for the Essential Works were completed in early-2022.

Options evaluation

The Queensland Government’s decision has been underpinned by the Paradise Dam Improvement Project Options Evaluation Report.

Sunwater assisted in the development of the Options Evaluations Report by undertaking technical assessment and testing, supporting the demand study and undertaking preliminary design of various remediation options.

Read the Paradise Dam Improvement Project Options Evaluation Report on the Department of Local Government, Water and Volunteers (DLGWV) website.

Past Paradise Dam Engagement Forums

The Paradise Dam Community Reference Group (PDCRG) and Paradise Dam Industry Forum (PDIF) were established to facilitate information sharing and constructive discussion throughout the period of the Paradise Dam Essential Works.

The PDCRG aimed to provide insight into a diverse range of perspectives on community safety and held 20 meetings between October 2019 and January 2022.

The PDCRG was independently chaired by Richard Wilson and then Mike McKay with members representing each of the three local councils, the local disaster manager groups, irrigators, growers, chamber of commerce, environment organisations and downstream residents.

The PDIF focused on identifying opportunities and exchanging ideas on ways to improve water security in the Burnett catchment and held 18 meetings (and 18 separate working group meetings) between February 2020 and January 2022.

The PDIF was also independently chaired by Stuart Armitage until June 2021 and consisted of five representatives from each of the following participating local industry groups: Bundaberg Fruit and Vegetable Growers, Canegrowers Isis, Bundaberg Regional Irrigators Group, Australian Macadamia Society, Citrus Australia and Avocados Australia.

In agreement with both groups, these two engagement forums were dissolved in early 2022 and replaced by a new engagement forum: the Paradise Dam Reference Group (PDRG), focused on the Paradise Dam Improvement Project.